McKenzie sets 90-day clock on Sascoc probe into Swimming SA

Sascoc given three months to probe the swimming federation and report monthly

McKenzie sets 90-day clock on Sascoc probe into Swimming SA

Sascoc now has 90 days to diagnose Swimming South Africa, a task team to deploy, monthly reports to file and a special general meeting set for 30 November. Those are the operational demands Sport Minister Gayton McKenzie laid out at a blunt media briefing at Parliament on 17 November, when he asked the South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee to launch a full investigation into the federation and stabilise it. The trigger was the decision by Tatjana Smith, South Africa’s most decorated Olympian, to change allegiances and swim under the Dutch flag from next month. She holds dual citizenship and is eligible to compete for the Netherlands.

The delivery record McKenzie laid out was damning. He devoted much of his scripted address to how the federation handled Smith, a swimmer with two Olympic gold medals and four Olympic medals in all, breaking off at one point to apologise to her directly.

“I want to stop right here for five seconds and to just apologise to Tatjana. She’s been treated in the worst possible way. They should be ashamed,” said McKenzie. “Tatjana has been treated like an enemy of this country.”

The dispute, as McKenzie recounted it, began at the 2023 World Championships in Fukuoka, Japan. On the morning of her first 100m breaststroke heat, Smith was handed a letter from the federation’s chief executive warning that any swimmer not wearing the sponsored brand would automatically be fined €2,000 for every heat and €20,000 for every final.

“There was no hearing, no discussion. Imagine reading that on the morning of a World Championship race,” said McKenzie.

Smith raced in her personal sponsor’s suit and won gold in the 200m breaststroke and silver in the 100m. Three weeks later, according to McKenzie, she received a one-line email with an invoice for €46,000 for wearing the “wrong” kit, while SSA simultaneously held on to her $35,000 prize money.

What followed was a long trail of unanswered correspondence. In January 2024 her manager wrote to the federation’s chief executive asking for the money; there was no reply. In March 2024 Smith asked again herself and received only a reminder of her outstanding invoice. Her manager told the federation that World Aquatics had confirmed it was not entitled to withhold the winnings and requested a meeting; that too was ignored, as was her use of the escalation process on the federation’s own website. By May 2024, two months before the Paris Olympics, Smith had to instruct lawyers to recover her own prize money from her own federation. Only then was it paid, with the interest following much later.

Before Paris, Smith had gone to Sascoc and asked in writing whether she could compete in a personal sponsor’s technical suit and goggles at the Olympic Games. Sascoc confirmed that she could. “She did not hide. She asked,” McKenzie said, putting on record, with paperwork in his possession, that claims suggesting otherwise were lies.

McKenzie made clear he did not accept SSA’s account of events. “I’m aware that many at SSA have a different version of these events. And we have heard that version or the various versions of that version,” he said. He noted that Smith never signed a sponsorship deal with Arena, that no disciplinary hearing was held, and that SSA’s own team management allowed her to race. The federation has since withdrawn the fine. He was scathing about SSA’s claim, made when the ministry met the federation on Monday, 16 November, that it had tried to reach Smith and felt she was ignoring it, confirming he holds documented evidence of her multiple emails about the fine and the unpaid prize money.

The investigation’s scope is broad. McKenzie has asked Sascoc to establish how the Arena sponsorship agreement works, what penalties were levied and who paid them, and whether other swimmers were fined or had money held back. It must also examine how money was spent on the Franschhoek High Performance Centre and the flaws in the federation’s constitution. “The federation is in ICU. And we should not run away from that,” said McKenzie.

Sascoc’s acting president, Lwandile Simelane, said the task team would have full terms of reference covering governance, administration, finances and the resolution of outstanding disputes. Its members are still to be confirmed and will inform the minister and SSA later this week. Beyond the 90-day deadline for a diagnosis and preliminary findings, Sascoc has committed to monthly reports to the minister’s office.

McKenzie was frank that he would have preferred to act himself. “If I could, I would come out there, and I will fire all of them immediately. That’s how I feel,” he said. “But I can’t. Even if I want to, we shall be suspended by World Aquatics. The law says Sascoc must deal with this first. I’ve asked Sascoc now to deal with this first.” While Sascoc hardly has a flawless leadership track record, and SSA has lurched from one crisis to another under it, it remains the overarching federation, and McKenzie is playing this one by the book.

Meanwhile, the constitutional provisions themselves came under fire. SSA’s constitution, approved in August 2024 and signed by its now suspended president and chief executive, contains two overlapping clauses: one suspends the membership of anyone who takes legal action against SSA without first following its dispute resolution process; the other goes further, stating that any member who goes to court “will automatically cease to be a member”. The document also classifies taking a dispute to the media as misconduct and requires any member referring a dispute to arbitration to bear the costs. Deputy Sport Minister Peace Mabe singled out the provision stripping members of their status for going to court, calling it unconstitutional and demanding it be scrapped immediately. “I want to declare that I have no confidence in the current leadership of Swimming SA,” she said.

“The message to every athlete is, if you are wronged, keep quiet,” said McKenzie.

For its part, SSA’s acting president, Zikie Molusi, said he would prefer not to give “running commentary” on issues that would form the basis of the investigation and pledged the federation’s full support for the process. He claimed the board had not known about the kit dispute until it received a lawyer’s letter about two and a half months ago, describing it as a matter between Smith and the operational team. SSA’s president, Alan Fritz, and chief executive, Shaun Adriaanse, were provisionally suspended by the Aquatics Integrity Unit in August.

Whether the task team’s members, once named this week, can deliver findings that hold within the 90-day window is now the question hanging over the federation.

Q&A

What deadlines did Minister Gayton McKenzie set for Sascoc's investigation into Swimming South Africa?

90 days to produce a diagnosis and preliminary findings, plus monthly reports to the minister's office and a special general meeting set for 30 November.

What must the Sascoc task team investigate?

The Arena sponsorship agreement and penalties, whether other swimmers were fined or had money withheld, spending on the Franschhoek High Performance Centre, and flaws in SSA's constitution.

Why did Tatjana Smith's treatment prompt the probe?

She was threatened with fines for wearing a non-sponsored suit at the 2023 World Championships, was invoiced €46,000, and had her $35,000 prize money withheld until she instructed lawyers before the Paris Olympics.

How has Sascoc responded?

Acting president Lwandile Simelane said the task team would have full terms of reference covering governance, administration, finances and outstanding disputes, with members to be confirmed later that week.