For Tom O’Toole, the closing minutes of Ireland’s Test against South Africa at a packed Aviva Stadium must have felt like a long walk to the gallows. The loosehead prop had been buried at the scrum all afternoon. When the game’s decisive set-piece arrived, an Irish put-in under their own posts with just three points in hand, it was Nick Timoney who came to his rescue, dialing up the channel-one answer Ireland had found all day. Games, as this one proved, are won and lost on moments like that.
The 12th Test of South Africa’s season ended with Ireland standing firm, but the Springboks still left with a bonus point that keeps Rassie Erasmus’s men on course for the final. For the countries hoping someone, anyone, might slow the South African juggernaut before next year’s World Cup, the result will be warmly received. A year after having Ireland on toast and demanding more rounds, the Springboks were made to pay the full asking price this time.
The scrum was supposed to be the instrument of their dominance, and for long stretches it was. South Africa extracted five penalties and two free kicks from that battle while conceding just one full penalty to Ireland. Their calling card had been examined up, down, inside and out all week, and the contest between the giant tighthead Wilco Louw and Andrew Porter was expected to sink the home side. Yet there was enough left in that debate to rule out any foregone conclusion.
Ireland, by contrast, played the more ambitious rugby, and were rewarded with performances of real quality from individuals. Rónan Kelleher, Josh van der Flier and the replacement Timoney stood out, and the man of the match award was effectively wrapped in green before half-time. Robert Baloucoune was box office. Every time he got his paws on the ball, some piece of magic seemed about to unfold. Beyond his aerial fetching, he was involved in three try-scoring incidents: the first and third were good, while the one in between saw him lose the ball as he stretched to touch down under pressure from Damian Willemse and Cameron Hanekom.
The match itself unfolded as a gripping game of chess where you could whack your opponent as you made your play. The aerial battle was full-on from the start, with Hugo Keenan and Baloucoune keeping the casualty rate down for the home side. There was also a battle of wills over penalties: whenever Ireland were offered a shot at three points, they drove past the exit and went to touch instead. The Boks were more measured early on, with Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu taking three points from his first sight of the sticks.
Ireland led at the break thanks to the quick response their coach would later praise. Kelleher got over in the corner just after Ireland had conceded a try to the excellent Morné van den Berg at the other end. Andy Farrell was full of admiration afterwards. “They’re not just the world champions but they’re the world No 1 as well and they’ve been playing outstanding rugby over the last 12 months,” he said. “So yeah, to come away with any kind of W we’ll take that. It was some effort by the lads. We kept turning up when we were trying to get back into the game after something disappointing, maybe scoring a try just after they did which shows the character of the lads.”
There will be homework for both camps. Farrell will likely raise the tries Ireland left unfinished, though creating chances is better than not creating them at all. The Boks, meanwhile, will review the three mistakes in the endgame that let Ireland hold out under intense pressure. The autumn series concludes in London next weekend: Ireland face Australia in the fifth-place final on Friday night, before South Africa take on France on Sunday in a mouthwatering showdown for the overall title.